Go back to the home page

The Film

   This movie has an online cover Prince Of Tears (2009)
Directed By: Yonfan


View Count: 1
Last Viewed:2010.11.10
First/Last Reviewed:2010.11.11/2011.03.07

ldh's rating

What ldh has recently...

  . Seen
  . Rated
  . Reviewed

Visit ldh's...

You can...

  . Comment on this review
  . Check reviews on IMDB

ldh's review

I remember having a conversation one day with a friend i was "educating" in Asian cinema, and giving him a few films, including Hong-Kong, Macau, Mainland and Taiwan. He laughed at the fact that i was making a distinction for something that to him was just "Chinese" films. However, each of those "Chinese" regions have a distinct coloration that permeates their film industry. In the span of a few months, i have seen five really outstanding Taiwanese films.  I must admit i have a weakness for films coming from Taiwan: they have a very artsy European feel in terms of the subject matters they touch, their slower pace, and their more contemplative nature. In that respect, they break away from the rest of Asia, although independent South Korean fares come close.

So here, i am going to cover those 5 films briefly: Prince Of Tears, How Are You Dad?, Hear Me, Tears, and Yang Yang. They are all from 2009, a prolific year for Taiwan, and cover epic historical landscapes, intimate personal relationships, quirky romances, and destructive obsessions.

Prince Of Tears (2009) is a fantastic film from renowned director Yonfan. With a large body of work focusing mostly on small independent films with gays and lesbians often at the center, Yonfan this time produced a stunning glossy piece of high Art. Lush and ornate, every single frame in the film will have you go "Wow!". Costumes, sets, art direction, cinematography are all simply stunning. The grand scale of the production is only matched by the grand scale of a troubling period of history the film portrays. The White Terror in Taiwan was traumatizing  for the country, and wasn't officially acknowledged and condemned till 1995. In short, after a devastating government-led massacre of 10's of thousands in 1947, the government declared Martial Law and thousands of people continued to simply disappeared, be imprisoned, and/or executed for decades to follow, under suspicion of being Communists. "Thousands" may not feel like much, but at the time, you have to understand that adjusted for population, it's as if McCarthism in the US had resulted in over 400,000 violent political assassinations! And i am using lower-bound estimates from what i could gather.

In this film, we follow a love triangle that gets caught into this political nightmare, with disastrous consequences. The film's scale is epic, but the story focuses on a few characters and their relationships with one another, giving that period in history a very human and personal face. The film is unnerving  as it under its gorgeous looks, it displays some of the most horrible human emotions and mob behaviors, misplaced ideas of national honor and counter-revolutionary impulses that are at least as detestable as the revolutionary impulses that were happening on the mainland right about the same time. This film could have fallen into so many traps, and maybe it did as i must admit i am no expert in the matter, but at least in broad strokes, around themes that anyone can relate to, the film did not fall into glorifying Communists in some way, or Mao's mainland government. This is not a left-wing statement about how the Reactionaries are worse than the Revolutionaries, or something to that effect. This is not Steven Soderbergh's Che. Instead, the film focuses on the mechanics of any such horrible political climates, the bribes, the influences, and the inexorable march of time that swallows inconsiderately the helpless, no matter which side those horrors happen on.

- Laurent Hasson